Odd Sentence Out Practice | Topper Cracker

Odd Sentence Out

The following five sentences, labeled 1 to 5, relate to a single topic. Four of these sentences can be arranged to form a logical paragraph. Identify the sentence that does not fit with the others and enter its number as your answer.

1. The tragedy of the commons articulates a systemic dilemma where individual rationality, when applied to shared, finite resources, leads inexorably to collective detriment.
2. In such scenarios, each user gains directly and significantly from further resource extraction, while the diffuse costs of depletion are distributed across the entire community, diluting individual accountability.
3. This fundamental misalignment between private benefit and social cost often precipitates an escalating cycle of exploitation, culminating in the degradation and eventual collapse of the common-pool resource.
4. Thus, without effective governance or clearly defined property rights, the inherent dynamics of common resources tend to favor short-term individual gains over long-term ecological sustainability.
5. However, empirical studies demonstrate that local communities, through established social norms and adaptive institutional designs, can often manage common resources sustainably, challenging the inevitability of Hardin's pessimistic prognosis.

Correct Answer: 5
Identification of the Theme: The core argument defines and elaborates on the mechanism by which individual rational self-interest leads to the degradation of shared environmental resources, a phenomenon known as the tragedy of the commons.
Logical Sequence of the Coherent Paragraph: 1-2-3-4.
Sentence 1: Introduces the central concept of the tragedy of the commons and its core tenet: individual rationality leading to collective detriment.
Sentence 2: Explains the underlying mechanism by contrasting concentrated individual benefits with diffused collective costs in resource exploitation.
Sentence 3: Describes the consequence of this mechanism, highlighting the escalating cycle of exploitation and eventual resource collapse.
Sentence 4: Concludes by reiterating the broad implication that common resources are vulnerable to short-term individual gains in the absence of proper governance.
Why Sentence 5 is the Odd One Out: Sentences 1, 2, 3, and 4 collectively define, explain the mechanism, detail the consequences, and summarize the inherent problem of the tragedy of the commons. Sentence 5, while topically related, shifts the focus from the problem's definition and dynamics to potential solutions and counter-arguments (community-based management and challenging the inevitability of degradation). It discusses management strategies and empirical evidence against the "pessimistic prognosis" rather than further elaborating on the nature of the tragedy itself.

← →

Keep Learning?